Supreme Court Rules On Balancing Surety Requirements with Personal Liberty In Multiple Bail Cases
In a significant ruling on August 22, the Supreme Court of India emphasised the need to balance requirement of sureties. It should be balanced with the constitutional right to personal liberty. When an accused person is granted bail in multiple cases but struggles to find separate sureties for each. This decision came during the hearing of a writ petition filed by Girish Gandhi. He had been granted bail in 13 different cases across various states. But, had continued to be incarcerated due to his inability to secure multiple sureties.
The bench, comprised Justices B.R. Gavai and K.V. Vishwanathan. They highlighted that sureties are crucial for ensuring the presence of the accused on bail. Although, imposing excessive surety conditions may violate the accused’s fundamental rights. The rights are mentioned under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The Court noted that requiring separate sureties for each case could amount to imposing “excessive bail conditions,”. This contradicts the very purpose of granting bail.
The petitioner had sought relief under Article 32 of the Constitution, requesting that the personal bonds and sureties he provided in one case be applicable to other cases as well. The respondent states, Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Punjab, and Uttarakhand, argued that separate sureties are required for each FIR, and a surety cannot be held liable for amounts exceeding the bond they furnished.
1 Comment
-
Pingback: Section 145 - Code of Civil Procedure - Enforcement Of Liability Of Surety. - ApniLaw


