Introduction
With almost everyone having access to a smartphone today, recording a protest and sharing it online has become easier than ever. As a result, the difference between professional journalists and ordinary content creators is becoming less clear. While authorities argue that it is difficult to distinguish between the two during protests, journalists believe that this confusion is sometimes used as an excuse for their mistreatment.
This issue has now reached the Supreme Court through petitions arising out of the October 2026 protests in Delhi against Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar and the Special Intensive Revision. On October 15, the Centre informed the Court that distinguishing between reel-makers and independent journalists was becoming increasingly difficult.
This raises an important question: should everyone recording and sharing events at a protest automatically receive the same protection as a journalist? The argument explored in this article is that reel-makers should not automatically be entitled to journalistic protection simply because they record and publish protest-related content. At the same time, their basic legal rights cannot be ignored.
Background of the Dispute
According to reporting by The Wire, Delhi Police detained more than 30 journalists on October 10 and 11 while covering the protests. Following these incidents, several petitions were filed before the Supreme Court, including petitions by the Delhi Union of Journalists and the Network of Women in Media, India. The petitioners alleged that the detention and physical handling of journalists by the police violated their fundamental rights under Articles 14, 19(1)(a), 19(1)(d) and 21 of the Constitution.
The Court brought together 46 related petitions and directed Delhi Police to produce the prohibitory orders issued under Section 163 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), along with details of the number of people detained. During the proceedings, an advocate also brought to the Court’s attention that electronic devices belonging to several journalists had been seized by the police. The Court emphasised that journalists should be allowed to carry out their professional duties without unnecessary interference. However, the police action reported during the protests raised questions about whether this principle had been followed in practice.
The Legal Position Under Indian law
The press does not enjoy a separate constitutional status from ordinary citizens. The freedom of the press is understood as part of the right to freedom of speech and expression under Article 19(1)(a) of the Constitution. Similarly, the right to assemble peacefully is protected under Article 19(1)(b). These rights are therefore available to both journalists and ordinary citizens, subject to the restrictions permitted by the Constitution.
There is also no general statutory immunity or special licence that automatically protects a person simply because they work as a journalist. Press accreditation is mainly an administrative arrangement and should not be confused with a legal guarantee of protection. In Mazdoor Kisan Shakti Sangathan v. Union of India, the Supreme Court recognised the importance of peaceful protests in a democratic society while also considering the rights of other people who may be affected. This makes it clear that the issue should not be limited to deciding who deserves the title of a journalist. Greater attention should be given to the nature of the activity being carried out, particularly the gathering and sharing of information with the public, and whether individuals are being subjected to arbitrary detention, physical assault or unnecessary seizure of their devices.
The Court’s Approach
The Supreme Court has not adopted a single, blanket position on who should qualify for journalistic protection. Justice Bagchi indicated that the Court would examine the different levels of protection that may be available to accredited journalists, freelancers, independent journalists and social media influencers. In one instance, the Court granted interim protection against coercive action to a woman journalist, but declined to extend the same relief automatically to all women journalists covering the protests. The protection was limited to the specific cases placed before it.
The Court also indicated that certain categories of journalists might require an additional level of protection while carrying out their duties. It further directed the police to preserve CCTV footage and other digital material connected with the incidents. This suggests that the Court is considering the issue on a case-by-case basis rather than treating everyone as either fully protected or completely unprotected. It has neither accepted the government’s position that content creators fall outside the scope of protection nor suggested that every individual recording a protest should automatically be recognised as a journalist.
Critical Analysis
The government’s argument is not entirely without merit. A protest site can be crowded, unpredictable and sometimes tense, making it difficult for police officers to verify everyone’s professional identity at the scene. If every person carrying a camera or recording a video were automatically treated as a journalist, it could create practical difficulties for law enforcement. However, this does not mean that the distinction should be used to deny protection to people who are genuinely involved in reporting public events.
First, difficulty in verifying someone’s identity should lead to the development of a reasonable procedure, rather than excluding independent journalists and content creators altogether. The more practical approach would be to consider the nature of the person’s activity. For instance, whether the individual is collecting information, recording events and sharing them with the public. Many freelance and independent journalists do not work for established media organisations, and making institutional employment the main requirement for protection would unfairly leave them out.
Second, the question of whether someone qualifies as a journalist should not be confused with their basic constitutional rights. Even if a content creator does not qualify for additional journalistic protection, they are still entitled to the protection of Article 21 against arbitrary detention and the unlawful use of force.
Therefore, the absence of a journalist’s identity cannot be treated as justification for mistreatment by the police.
Third, the seizure of electronic devices deserves particular attention. Smartphones and cameras may contain important recordings, personal information and details about confidential sources. Unnecessary seizure of these devices can interfere with the ability of journalists to report events and may also expose information that should remain protected.
Fourth, there is a possibility that unclear rules could lead to selective enforcement, where some individuals are allowed to report freely while others face unnecessary interference. A separate Public Interest Litigation seeking a National Minimum Protocol for the Safety of Journalists and Media Personnel during public protests could help address this concern by establishing clear standards for police conduct in advance.
Finally, the Court’s decision not to grant blanket protection to an entire category of people is understandable. Simply claiming to be a journalist, or a woman journalist, should not automatically establish that every allegation made in an individual case is correct. Each matter must still be examined on its own facts and evidence.
Conclusion
The issue requires the Supreme Court to find a balance between two extreme positions. On one hand, recording a protest should not automatically make every content creator a journalist entitled to additional professional protection. On the other hand, those who do not carry a press card or work for an established media organisation should not be left without legal protection. A more reasonable approach would be to recognise the importance of newsgathering, establish clear guidelines for police conduct during protests and require proper justification before detaining individuals or seizing their electronic devices. Most importantly, the basic rights guaranteed under Articles 19 and 21 should not depend on whether someone possesses a press accreditation card. Until clear guidelines are established, anyone genuinely engaged in reporting public events should be protected against arbitrary action by the authorities, regardless of the professional label attached to them.


