Case: Motor Accident Compensation Appeal concerning the death of Mohit
Introduction
The Himachal Pradesh High Court has held that, in the absence of evidence establishing financial dependency, the father and siblings of a deceased bachelor cannot ordinarily be treated as dependents on his earnings for calculating motor accident compensation. The Court observed that the mother would ordinarily qualify as a dependent, while the father and siblings would not automatically be entitled to dependency compensation.
A Single Bench of Justice Sushil Kukreja held that the deceased’s father would ordinarily be presumed to have an independent source of income, while the siblings would either be earning independently or dependent on their father.
Background
The claimants approached the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Paonta Sahib, seeking compensation of ₹25 lakh following the death of Mohit, aged 31, in a road accident on November 25, 2020.
According to the claimants, a car driven rashly and negligently hit the deceased’s motorcycle near Village Khodri, causing fatal injuries. They submitted that Mohit was working as a Munshi and earning ₹15,000 per month. They also claimed that his parents and two sisters were financially dependent on his earnings.
The Tribunal awarded compensation of ₹17,20,400 along with 7.5% annual interest.
Aggrieved by the award, the claimants approached the High Court, challenging the assessment of the deceased’s monthly income and the Tribunal’s treatment of the family members as dependents.
Decision
The High Court upheld the Tribunal’s assessment of the deceased’s monthly income at ₹8,250. It noted that the claimants had failed to produce documentary evidence establishing his alleged monthly salary of ₹15,000.
On the question of dependency, the Court held that the deceased’s father and two sisters could not be considered dependents in the absence of evidence demonstrating their financial dependence on his earnings. It observed that the father would ordinarily be presumed to have an independent income, while the sisters would either be earning independently or dependent upon their father.
Accordingly, the Court considered only the deceased’s mother as a dependent for calculating the loss of dependency.
The Court recalculated the compensation by applying a 40% addition towards future prospects, deducting 50% towards the deceased’s personal expenses and retaining the multiplier of 16.
The loss of dependency was consequently calculated at ₹11,08,800. An additional ₹70,000 was awarded under conventional heads, bringing the total compensation to ₹11,78,800.
The Court directed that the compensation be payable exclusively to the deceased’s mother.
Implications
The judgment highlights the importance of establishing actual financial dependency when claiming compensation under the Motor Vehicles Act for the death of a bachelor.
It clarifies that a family relationship alone does not automatically establish financial dependency for the purpose of calculating loss of dependency. Courts may examine the circumstances of individual family members and require evidence to establish their dependence on the deceased’s income.
The ruling also emphasises the importance of documentary evidence when establishing the deceased’s income, as an unsupported salary claim may not be accepted while calculating compensation.


