Introduction
The Telangana High Court has held that a Family Court or High Court cannot grant a divorce decree solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. However, the Court clarified that prolonged separation and the absence of any possibility of reconciliation can be considered along with other circumstances while deciding a divorce appeal.
A Division Bench of Justice K. Lakshman and Justice K. Sujana made the observation while allowing a husband’s appeal against the dismissal of his divorce petition. The Court dissolved the marriage subject to the husband paying ₹50 lakh to his son within three months.
Background
The appellant-husband, an engineer settled in the United States, sought dissolution of his marriage under Section 13(1)(ia) and Section 13(1)(ib) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955, alleging cruelty and desertion.
The couple married in February 2002 and had a son in 2005. The husband alleged that his wife insulted his family, frequently left the matrimonial home without reasonable cause and had a son from a premarital relationship. He further claimed that she left for her parental home during pregnancy in October 2004 and never returned.
The husband also claimed to have obtained a divorce decree from a Texas court in 2009. However, he was advised to obtain a divorce decree from a competent Indian court.
The wife opposed the divorce petition, alleging that her husband’s family had demanded additional dowry and refused to take her and their son to the United States.
The Family Court dismissed the husband’s divorce petition. Challenging the decision, he approached the Telangana High Court.
Decision
The High Court examined the allegations of cruelty and desertion and found that the husband had failed to establish them through sufficient evidence.
Regarding the allegation that the wife had a child from a premarital relationship, the Bench observed that the husband had not produced any evidence to substantiate the claim. The Court held that making serious allegations without supporting evidence was insufficient to establish cruelty.
The Court also found that the husband had failed to establish the essential elements of desertion, including the factum of separation, animus deserendi (intention to permanently abandon the matrimonial relationship), absence of consent and absence of reasonable cause for leaving the matrimonial home.
However, the Court considered the prolonged separation between the parties. It noted that they had been living separately for nearly two decades and that mediation efforts had failed to bring about reconciliation. The husband had also been residing in the United States for several years.
The Bench clarified that neither a Family Court nor a High Court could grant divorce solely on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. Nevertheless, the prolonged separation and lack of possibility of reunion could be considered alongside other relevant circumstances while deciding the appeal.
Considering the overall circumstances, the Court dissolved the marriage by granting a decree of divorce. It directed the husband to pay ₹50 lakh to his son within three months. The Court further granted liberty to the son to take appropriate steps against the father in case of non-compliance.
Implications
The judgment clarifies the distinction between the statutory grounds for divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act and the principle of irretrievable breakdown of marriage.
Irretrievable breakdown is not an independent statutory ground under Section 13 of the Hindu Marriage Act. The Supreme Court, however, has the distinct constitutional power under Article 142 to dissolve a marriage on this ground to do complete justice between the parties.
The ruling also highlights that prolonged separation and failed reconciliation efforts may be relevant circumstances in matrimonial appeals, but they cannot independently replace the statutory requirements for granting divorce.
Further, the decision emphasises that serious allegations of cruelty and desertion must be supported by cogent evidence before a court can grant matrimonial relief.


