A retired army officer was chosen as the head of an ECHS Polyclinic in India, despite being two months over the age limit set by the policy. The other three candidates feel this selection was unfair. Could this decision be challenged in the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT)? What are the chances of success, especially if higher ECHS officials are trying to hide the issue?

Yes, the decision to appoint the retired officer can be challenged in the Armed Forces Tribunal (AFT) on the grounds of violation of the ECHS policy. The chances of success depend on the evidence presented and the AFT’s assessment of the fairness of the selection process. While attempts to hide the issue may complicate matters, the AFT can investigate and issue a decision based on merit.