Introduction
The Kerala High Court has held that a second DNA test cannot be ordered merely because the party challenging the original report claims that another examination would cause no prejudice. The Court ruled that a fresh DNA examination requires concrete evidence of material defects in the original testing process. It also observed that repeated DNA examinations cannot be permitted simply because a party is dissatisfied with an unfavourable scientific report.
Justice Easwaran S. set aside the Munsiff’s Court order directing a second DNA examination at the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, Hyderabad.
Background
The petitioner approached the Munsiff’s Court, Parappanangadi, seeking a declaration that he was not the biological father of two children born to the first defendant on June 11, 2012.
The dispute arose from allegations that the petitioner had sexually assaulted the first defendant in September 2011 and was the biological father of the children. A criminal case was registered against him under Sections 376, 450 and 506 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code. He was also remanded to judicial custody for 36 days before obtaining bail.
During the civil proceedings, the petitioner sought DNA profiling of the parties. The trial court referred them to the Rajiv Gandhi Centre for Biotechnology, Thiruvananthapuram. On November 7, 2016, the Centre submitted a report concluding that the petitioner was not the biological father of the children.
The defendants subsequently challenged the report and sought a second DNA examination at the Centre for DNA Fingerprinting and Diagnostics, Hyderabad. Although the trial court initially rejected their application, the High Court directed reconsideration of the request in October 2024.
Following reconsideration, the expert who conducted the original examination was examined and cross-examined. However, the trial court allowed the second DNA test despite the defendants failing to establish any discrepancy in the original report. Aggrieved by this decision, the petitioner approached the High Court.
Decision
The High Court examined the provisions of Order XXVI Rule 10A of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which governs scientific investigations conducted through a commission. It observed that the report forms part of the judicial record and can be challenged through appropriate evidence and examination of the expert.
The Court noted that the defendants had participated in the original DNA examination without objecting to the institution selected for conducting the test. They also failed to establish any material defect in the report, even after examining the expert.
The Court rejected the argument that the scientist was unqualified because she held a Ph.D. in Botany rather than Forensic Science. It noted her specialisation in Biotechnology and her experience in genome-related work. The Court further observed that neither Section 45 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, nor Section 39 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, prescribes a specific academic degree as a mandatory qualification for an expert.
The Court held that a second DNA examination requires specific and verifiable grounds, such as sample contamination, improper sealing, sample mixing, fraud during collection or violations of mandatory forensic procedures. Mere dissatisfaction with an earlier report cannot justify another examination.
It also considered the implications of compulsory DNA testing on bodily autonomy and the right to privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution.
Relying on S. Veeralakshmi v. The Superintendent of Police and Others, the Court reiterated that parties cannot repeatedly seek expert opinions until they obtain a favourable result.
Accordingly, the High Court allowed the Original Petition, set aside the Munsiff’s Court order dated January 31, 2026, and dismissed the application seeking a second DNA examination.
Implications
The judgment establishes that a second DNA test cannot be ordered as a routine measure whenever a party disputes an existing scientific report. Courts must examine whether the applicant has demonstrated specific defects affecting the reliability of the original examination.
It also highlights the importance of protecting bodily autonomy and privacy while considering applications for compulsory DNA testing. The ruling reinforces the evidentiary value of properly conducted scientific examinations and prevents repeated testing based solely on dissatisfaction with the outcome.


