Code: Section 44 BNS
If in the exercise of the right of private defence against an assault which reasonably
causes the apprehension of death, the defender be so situated that he cannot effectually exercise that right without risk of harm to an innocent person, his right of private defence
extends to the running of that risk.
Illustration.
A is attacked by a mob who attempt to murder him. He cannot effectually exercise his
right of private defence without firing on the mob, and he cannot fire without risk of harming
young children who are mingled with the mob. A commits no offence if by so firing he harms
any of the children.
Explanation of Section 44 BNS
This section addresses a crucial legal dilemma: What happens if an innocent person is accidentally harmed while defending oneself against a deadly attack?
Key Takeaways:
- Right to Self-Defense Still Exists: Even if an innocent bystander might be harmed, the right of private defense remains valid if exercised in good faith.
- No Intentional Harm: The defender must not intend to harm the innocent person; the harm must be an unintended consequence.
- No Other Option Available: If the defender had no reasonable way to prevent harm to the innocent person while saving their own life, they are not liable.
Illustrations
Example 1: Knife Attack in a Crowd
A man is attacked with a knife in a crowded marketplace. He defends himself with a stick, but in the process, an innocent bystander is accidentally hit and injured.
✅ Allowed under Section 44 – The defender acted in self-defense with no intention of harming the bystander.
Example 2: Gunfire in a Home Invasion
An armed burglar breaks into a house and starts shooting. The homeowner, in self-defense, fires back. One of the bullets accidentally hits a family member.
✅ Allowed under Section 44 – The homeowner was exercising their right of private defense without intending harm to the family member.
Example 3: Hostage Situation
A person is held at gunpoint. A rescuer tries to intervene and attacks the criminal, but in the struggle, an innocent person is injured.
✅ Allowed under Section 44 – The harm to the innocent was unintentional and unavoidable in the act of self-defense.
Common Questions & Answers on Section 44 BNS
1. Can I claim self-defense if I accidentally harm an innocent person?
Yes, as long as the act was in good faith, unintentional, and unavoidable while defending yourself.
2. What if I had another option to escape?
If a reasonable escape was possible without causing harm, but you still caused harm, you may not be protected under Section 44.
3. Does this section apply to defending others, not just myself?
Yes! The right of private defense applies to protecting yourself and others from a deadly attack.
4. Can I use a firearm for self-defense in a public place?
Only if:
- The attack is deadly,
- Using the firearm is necessary, and
- There is no reasonable alternative to escape or neutralize the threat.
5. What if the harm to an innocent person was intentional?
Then Section 44 will not apply, and the act could be considered a crime.
Conclusion
Section 44 BNS balances self-defense and public safety, ensuring that a person defending themselves is not punished if harm to an innocent person was unintentional and unavoidable. However, unnecessary or reckless actions are not protected under this section.
For expert legal insights, visit ApniLaw today! 🚀
