Supreme Court Questions Fresh SLP Filing After Withdrawal Without Leave, Refers Matter To Larger Bench
New Delhi, July 29: The Supreme Court has recently challenged the view that filing a fresh Special Leave Petition (SLP). This remains an option if an SLP was previously dismissed through a non-speaking order or withdrawal without leave. This view had been previously taken by a Division Bench in the case of S. Narahari And Ors. v. S.R. Kumar And Ors.
In its latest order, the Supreme Court relied on Order XXIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This pertains to the withdrawal of suits. The Bench comprised Justices Dipankar Datta and Prashant Kumar Mishra. They emphasised that a party cannot reinitiate proceedings after withdrawing a plea without obtaining the court’s leave.
“A party having withdrawn the proceedings before a competent Court and not having obtained leave of such Court to file a fresh proceeding ought not to be permitted to have a second bite at the cherry,” the Bench remarked.
Given that the issue in Narahari’s case was referred to a larger bench, and the current case was also heard by a two-judge bench, the matter was adjourned indefinitely. The Court provided liberty to mention the SLP for relisting after the larger bench renders its decision.
Leave a Comment


