Index
- Introduction: Surrogacy
- Origin And Formation
- Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2019
- Eligibility Criteria
- Factors Behind The Ban Of Indian Surrogacy
- Surrogacy Regulation Act, 2020
- Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021
- Key Provisions Of Legislation
- Rules For Surrogacy Clinics
- Rules And Procedure For Surrogacy
- Registration Process For Surrogacy Clinics
- Advantages Of Being A Surrogate Mother
- Drawbacks Of Being A Surrogate Mother
- Critiquing Surrogacy Regulations
- Understanding Assisted Reproductive Technology Act
- Definition of Assisted Reproductive Technology (ART)
- Regulations For ART Clinics And Banks
- Criteria For Sperm Donation And Assisted Reproductive Technologies
- Management Of Assisted Reproductive Procedures
- Misconduct In Surrogacy And ART Practices
- Latest Judgement
- Conclusion
Introduction: Surrogacy
Surrogacy entails the surrogate mother carrying a child for another person, relinquishing care to the intended parents post-birth. It involves intricate legal and medical procedures, necessitating professional guidance and support networks like Fertility World Surrogacy Center India. Notably, India has permitted commercial surrogacy since 2002.Origin And Formation
The Law Commission of India, in its 208th report, stressed the necessity for legislation to regulate commercial surrogacy, citing concerns such as its predominantly foreign clientele, absence of a robust legal framework, and the potential exploitation of surrogate mothers, often driven by financial constraints and limited education. Consequently, the Indian government issued a notification in 2015 prohibiting surrogacy for foreign nationals. The first Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha in November 2016, with key provisions including a complete ban on commercial surrogacy, stipulating that the surrogate must be a close relative of the intended parents, requiring proof of infertility for couples, mandatory registration of all surrogacy clinics, maintenance of surrogacy records for 25 years by registered clinics, and barring single parents, couples living in India, homosexuals, unmarried or childless women from participating in surrogacy. However, the law failed to be implemented and lapsed after the Parliament’s dissolution.Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2019
The Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2019, aimed to regulate surrogacy in India by prohibiting commercial surrogacy and allowing only altruistic surrogacy. Altruistic surrogacy involves no financial transactions except for medical expenses and insurance for the surrogate mother. The bill also specified eligibility criteria for intended parents, surrogate mothers, and outlined the establishment of surrogacy boards at the national and state levels for overseeing surrogacy arrangements. Additionally, it aimed to safeguard the rights and welfare of surrogate mothers and children born through surrogacy. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Bill, 2019, was presented in the Lok Sabha on July 15, 2019, and approved by the Lok Sabha on August 5, 2019. Subsequently, it was referred to a select committee for additional deliberation.Eligibility Criteria
For surrogacy, couples must have been married for at least five years. Additionally, they need to provide a necessity certificate along with an eligibility certificate when requested. Moreover, they must commit to not abandoning any child born through surrogacy. The surrogate, a relative of the intended couple, must be married with children of her own and aged between 25 and 35, with no prior surrogacy experience. An insurance cover is mandatory, not just for the pregnancy period but also post-pregnancy care for the surrogate. The bill also aims to regulate surrogacy clinic operations and mandates registration to avoid service suspension. However, the selection of a child’s sex through surrogacy is prohibited under the Act.Factors Behind The Ban Of Indian Surrogacy
In India, women were compelled to stay until childbirth for the intended parents, devoid of family support, and abandoned post-pregnancy. Surrogates received a fraction of what the agencies charged the intended parents, typically around $4,000 to $5,000 as compensation. This commercial surrogacy exploited financial vulnerabilities, poverty, and lack of education among surrogates, who were repeatedly drawn into the process. Consequently, their health suffered as they were effectively treated as “baby-making machines” year after year. Surrogate mothers lacked the essential support services for themselves and their families during this taxing journey. The Government of India has taken steps to ensure the safety of all involved in the surrogacy process.Surrogacy Regulation Act, 2020
The new Surrogacy Regulation Act, 2020, allowing any woman willing to become a surrogate mother was approved by the Union Cabinet on February 26, 2020. Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the Bill was delayed but is expected to be introduced as Bill 2021 in the lower house of Parliament during its upcoming session. This bill represents a significant improvement over the Surrogacy Regulation Act of 2019, addressing its loopholes. However, it still follows a need-based approach rather than a rights-based approach. Before it can take effect and fulfil its purpose, it must be enacted into law and receive presidential assent. The proposed surrogacy legislation includes the establishment of regulatory bodies such as the National Surrogacy Board at the central level, State Surrogacy Boards at the state level, and competent authorities or agencies for Union Territories. It sets minimum standards for surrogacy clinics’ physical infrastructure, laboratory equipment, and professional staff. The legislation also bans commercial surrogacy based on recommendations from the Law Commission of India, allowing only altruistic surrogacy to prevent the growth of the uterus rental industry and protect surrogate mothers from exploitation. This ban extends to fashionable surrogacy not based on medical necessity but for convenience purposes. Countries such as Australia, New Zealand, the United Kingdom, Canada, Netherlands, and South Africa are also adopting similar surrogacy regulations. The Surrogacy (Regulation) Act of 2019 mandated “proven infertility” in at least one intended couple member for surrogacy eligibility, but the 2020 Bill expanded eligibility to couples with a medical indication necessitating gestational surrogacy. Additionally, widowed or divorced Indian women aged between 35 and 45 intending to undergo surrogacy are eligible under the new regulations.Surrogacy (Regulation) Act, 2021
Under the Surrogacy (Regulation) Act of 2021, surrogacy is permitted for widowed or divorced women aged 35 to 45, as well as legally married couples, if a medical condition necessitates it. The act strictly prohibits commercial surrogacy, imposing severe penalties such as imprisonment for up to 10 years and fines of up to Rs 10 lakh. Altruistic surrogacy is the only allowed form, where no monetary transactions occur, and the surrogate mother must be genetically related to the intended parents.Key Provisions Of The Legislation
The Surrogacy (Regulations) Act of 2021, which contains eight chapters and 54 sections governing surrogacy in India, was granted the President’s assent on December 25th, 2021. Section 2 of the Act delineates key definitions. Altruistic surrogacy, as per Section 2(b), restricts compensation to medical expenses, insurance, and prescribed costs for the surrogate mother, disallowing any additional charges or incentives. Commercial surrogacy, defined in Section 2(g), encompasses all forms of monetary rewards but is prohibited under the Act. Section 2(h) clarifies ‘couple’ as a legally married pair, both above the age of 21 for the man and 18 for the woman. Section 2(r) explains ‘intending couple’ as those aiming to become parents through surrogacy, with age criteria specified for females (23-50 years) and males (26-55 years) under Section 4(iii)(c)(I). Section 2(s) defines ‘intending women’ as females aged 35-45, including widows or divorced individuals seeking surrogacy. Additionally, Section 2(zd) outlines ‘surrogacy’ as a process wherein a woman carries and delivers a child for an intending couple, subsequently relinquishing parental rights to them after birth.Rules For Surrogacy Clinics
Section 3 of the Act mandates the registration of surrogacy clinics for conducting surrogacy procedures. It explicitly prohibits commercial surrogacy, emphasising that registered surrogacy clinics, paediatricians, gynaecologists, or any medical practitioners must not engage in such practices. All surrogacy-related procedures must occur exclusively at registered clinics, with no honorary employment allowed. Additionally, the Act strictly prohibits sex selection and the storage of human embryos or gametes for surrogacy purposes.Rules And Procedure For Surrogacy
IPC Section 420, IPC Section 415, Elements of Cheating, Punishment for Cheating, Characteristics of Offences, Offences Related to IPC 420, Latest Updates on IPC 420, Indian Penal Code Amendments, Fraudulent Activities under IPC, Legal Perspective on Cheating- Under Section 4 of the Act, any unregistered surrogacy clinic is barred from involvement, collaboration, or support in surrogacy activities and procedures which is further mentioned in chapter IV of the Act. They are also prohibited from hiring individuals lacking the necessary qualifications, whether on an honorary basis or for payment, in connection with surrogacy services. Moreover, storing human gametes or embryos for surrogacy purposes is strictly prohibited, except for authorised purposes such as sperm banks, IVF, or medical research.
- Section 6 of the Act mandates that the surrogate mother be fully informed about the potential side effects and impacts of surrogacy procedures in a language she comprehends, and her consent must be documented in writing. Furthermore, according to Section 7, it is strictly prohibited to abandon a child born through surrogacy due to birth defects, genetic conditions, or any medical issues, regardless of whether the abandonment occurs in India or outside of it.
- Section 8 of the Act stipulates that a child born through surrogacy will be legally regarded as the biological offspring of the intending couple, possessing all rights granted to a natural child by existing laws. Additionally, as outlined in Section 10, no entity or individual has the authority to compel a surrogate mother to undergo an abortion, except under specific circumstances that may be defined by prescribed conditions.
Registration Process For Surrogacy Clinics
- Section 11 of the Act mandates that surrogacy clinics must obtain proper registration under the legislation before providing any surrogacy services or operating a surrogacy centre. Within sixty days of obtaining the necessary authorization, every surrogacy centre involved in conducting surrogacy procedures, whether partial or complete, must submit an application for registration.
- Section 12 of the Act outlines the procedure for obtaining a certificate of registration for surrogacy clinics. Upon thorough examination and confirmation that the applicant has fulfilled all stipulated criteria and paid the required fees, the relevant authority will issue the certificate of registration. However, if the authority finds that the applicant has not met the necessary requirements, the application may be rejected, with detailed reasons for rejection documented in writing.
- Section 13 permits the cancellation or suspension of registration upon receiving complaints or taking suo motu action. In such cases, the clinic is required to provide justification as to why their registration should not be revoked or suspended, based on the reasons specified in the notice.
- Section 14 allows for an appeal to be lodged within 30 days from the date of receiving the rejection order. In addition, Section 15 mandates the establishment of the National Assisted Reproductive Technology and Surrogacy Registry, while Section 16 specifies that entities registered under Section 15 of the Act must also register under Section 9 of the Assisted Reproductive Technology Act.
- Section 17 mandates the establishment of the National Assisted Reproductive Technology and Surrogacy Registry to register surrogacy clinics under the Act. This registry will be referred to as the National Assisted Reproductive Technology and Surrogacy Registry. Regarding meetings, as outlined in Section 19, a meeting must be conducted every six months, chaired by the chairperson or, in their absence, the vice-chairperson. Decisions on all matters discussed in the meeting will be made based on the majority vote.
- Section 21 outlines the grounds for disqualifying members, including insolvency, moral misconduct, physical or mental incapacity, actions prejudicial to public interest, or any other reasons deemed appropriate by the Central Government indicating misbehaviour or incapacity. The removal of a member can only be done by order of the Central Government. Additionally, Section 24 allows for the re-appointment of an ex officio member for two consecutive terms.
- Ex officio members are eligible for re-appointment for two consecutive terms according to Section 24. Section 25 outlines the board’s responsibilities, which include advising the Central Government on surrogacy matters, conducting periodic reviews and monitoring of Act implementation, establishing a code of conduct for clinic personnel, supervising clinic operations, boards, and registries, and fulfilling any other prescribed functions.
- According to Section 35 of the Act, the Central Government must appoint an authority for each territory within 90 days of the Act’s commencement, while the State Government should appoint at least one authority for the state or a specific part of it. Section 37 delineates the powers of these authorities, which include summoning individuals violating Act provisions, searching suspected premises, requesting documents related to violations, and exercising any other powers prescribed as per the situation and case at hand.
- Under Section 40 of the Act, any individual or entity that prevents an intending couple from following altruistic surrogacy procedures can face imprisonment for up to five years and a fine of up to five lakh rupees for the initial offence. For subsequent offences, the punishment includes imprisonment of up to ten years and a fine of up to ten lakh rupees. Furthermore, Section 43 classifies all offences under this Act as cognizable, non-bailable, and non-compoundable.
- Chapter VIII encompasses the authority to establish rules, regulations, conduct search and seizure operations, address difficulties, and establish transitional provisions. Section 46 mandates the maintenance of records for 25 years, unless related to ongoing criminal or other proceedings, where they must be retained until the proceedings conclude. These records must be accessible for inspection upon request as necessary.
- Section 47 empowers the appropriate authority to conduct a search and seizure of records if there is a reasonable belief that an act has been carried out.


