By using this site, you agree to the Privacy Policy and Terms of Use.
Accept
ApniLawApniLawApniLaw
  • Home
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Our Services
  • Law Forum
  • Legal News
  • Judgments
  • Knowledge Hub
    • Bare Acts
      • BNS
      • BNSS
      • BSA
      • CrPC
      • CPC
      • DPDP
      • Hindu Marriage Act
      • Hindu Succession Act
      • The Hindu Adoptions And Maintenance Act
      • The Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act
      • IPC
      • Juvenile Justice Act
      • POCSO
      • Special Marriage Act
      • The Specific Relief Act
    • Supreme Court
    • High Court
    • Legal Articles
    • UPSC
    • Job Updates
    • Marriage and Divorce
    • Land Dispute & Will
    • Civil
    • Criminal
  • About Us
Reading: Section 11 of Indian Evidence Act vs Section 10 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam: Facts Consistent or Inconsistent With Facts in Issue
Share
Notification Show More
Font ResizerAa
ApniLawApniLaw
Font ResizerAa
  • Home
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Our Services
  • Law Forum
  • Legal News
  • Judgments
  • Knowledge Hub
  • About Us
  • Home
  • Find a Lawyer
  • Our Services
  • Law Forum
  • Legal News
  • Judgments
  • Knowledge Hub
    • Bare Acts
    • Supreme Court
    • High Court
    • Legal Articles
    • UPSC
    • Job Updates
    • Marriage and Divorce
    • Land Dispute & Will
    • Civil
    • Criminal
  • About Us
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
  • Advertise
© 2022 Foxiz News Network. Ruby Design Company. All Rights Reserved.
ApniLaw > Blog > Legal Articles > Acts > Section 11 of Indian Evidence Act vs Section 10 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam: Facts Consistent or Inconsistent With Facts in Issue
ActsBSA

Section 11 of Indian Evidence Act vs Section 10 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam: Facts Consistent or Inconsistent With Facts in Issue

Amna Kabeer
Last updated: January 17, 2026 8:35 pm
Amna Kabeer
10 months ago
Share
Evidence Act vs BSA – India’s New Evidence Law
Evidence Act vs BSA – India’s New Evidence Law
SHARE

Introduction

Section 11 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 and Section 10 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 serve the same legal purpose. Both provisions expand the concept of relevancy in evidence law. They allow courts to admit facts that are otherwise irrelevant when those facts either contradict facts in issue or make their existence or non-existence highly probable or improbable. These sections ensure that courts do not ignore surrounding circumstances that logically or physically affect the truth of a case.

Contents
IntroductionHow Do These Sections Define “Facts Inconsistent with Facts in Issue”?How Do These Provisions Address Probability and Improbability?Are the Texts of Section 11 IEA and Section 10 BSA Different?What Do the Illustrations under These Sections Explain?Why Are These Provisions Important for the Plea of Alibi?How Do Courts Apply the Test of Physical or Logical Impossibility?Does the Burden of Proof Shift under These Sections?What Is the Judicial Approach in Criminal Trials?Has the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam Changed the Legal Position?Conclusion

How Do These Sections Define “Facts Inconsistent with Facts in Issue”?

Both Section 11 IEA and Section 10 BSA treat inconsistency as a ground of relevancy. A fact becomes relevant when it directly contradicts a fact in issue or a relevant fact. For example, if the prosecution claims that the accused committed a murder at a specific place and time, evidence showing that the accused was present at a distant location at the same time becomes relevant. The inconsistency itself makes the evidence admissible.

How Do These Provisions Address Probability and Improbability?

The second limb of both sections focuses on probability. A fact becomes relevant if, by itself or when combined with other facts, it makes the existence or non-existence of a fact in issue highly probable or highly improbable. The law does not require the fact to be independently relevant. Its value lies in its logical effect on the main issue. This allows courts to consider contextual facts that strengthen or weaken the likelihood of the prosecution or defence story.

Are the Texts of Section 11 IEA and Section 10 BSA Different?

There is no textual difference between the two provisions. Section 10 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam reproduces Section 11 of the Indian Evidence Act verbatim. Both clauses are identical. The illustrations provided under both sections are also the same. This shows clear legislative intent to continue the settled principles of relevancy without modification under the new evidence law.

What Do the Illustrations under These Sections Explain?

The illustrations clarify how the sections operate in practice. One illustration explains the plea of alibi, where the accused proves presence at another place during the commission of the offence. Another illustration shows how evidence of a person being alive becomes relevant when the issue is whether that person is dead. These examples demonstrate how inconsistency and improbability make otherwise irrelevant facts admissible.

Why Are These Provisions Important for the Plea of Alibi?

The plea of alibi is the most common application of Section 11 IEA and Section 10 BSA. When an accused claims that they were elsewhere at the time of the offence, that fact directly contradicts the prosecution case. Courts admit such evidence under these provisions because it creates a physical impossibility of the accused committing the crime. However, courts require strict proof of alibi because it directly challenges the prosecution’s version.

ApniLaw AI

Need the case law behind this point?

Ask ApniLaw AI in plain words. Every point of the answer shows the judgment paragraph or Act section behind it, with its page and paragraph number.

Explore ApniLaw AI

How Do Courts Apply the Test of Physical or Logical Impossibility?

Courts apply a strict judicial test while admitting evidence under these sections. The inconsistency must be real and convincing. Mere doubt is not enough. The defence must show that the prosecution version becomes physically or logically impossible. For example, if an accused claims to be in Kerala while the crime occurred in Delhi at the same time, the court examines travel feasibility, timing, and corroboration before accepting the claim.

Does the Burden of Proof Shift under These Sections?

The prosecution always bears the primary burden of proving guilt beyond reasonable doubt. However, when the accused raises a plea under Section 11 IEA or Section 10 BSA, the burden shifts to the accused to establish the inconsistent or improbable fact. Courts have consistently held that alibi evidence must be proved with certainty and supported by reliable material.

What Is the Judicial Approach in Criminal Trials?

Indian courts have repeatedly emphasized caution while applying these sections. In cases like Binay Kumar Singh v. State of Bihar, the Supreme Court held that alibi evidence must be tested with great care. Courts usually assess the prosecution evidence first. Only after the prosecution establishes a prima facie case does the court examine whether the defence evidence creates a genuine inconsistency or improbability.

Has the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam Changed the Legal Position?

The Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam has not altered the scope or application of this principle. Section 10 BSA continues the same rule that existed under Section 11 IEA. Criminal trials, civil proceedings, and evidentiary standards remain unaffected. Courts will continue to rely on earlier judicial interpretations while applying the new provision.

Conclusion

These provisions prevent mechanical application of relevancy rules. They allow courts to consider real-world probabilities and impossibilities. By admitting facts that expose inconsistencies or improbabilities, the law ensures fairness to the accused and accuracy in judicial findings. Section 11 IEA and Section 10 BSA together reinforce logical reasoning as the foundation of evidence law in India.

Join Telegram Channel Join WhatsApp Channel

You Might Also Like

What Types of Work Are Banned for Children and Adolescents Under the Act? (Section 3)

How to File a Complaint on the National Cyber Crime Reporting Portal (NCRP) – Step-by-Step Guide

What is the Maximum Maintenance Amount Under Section 9 Of Senior Citizens Act?

Consent Clause in PPP Land Acquisition: Understanding the 70% and 80% Rule under Section 2(2) of the 2013 Act

Section 32 of the Indian Evidence Act vs Section 26 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam: Dying Declaration and Exceptions to Hearsay

TAGGED:Bharatiya Sakshya AdhiniyamBSAFactsFacts in IssueSection 10 BSA
Share This Article
Facebook Whatsapp Whatsapp Telegram Print
Previous Article Evidence Act vs BSA – India’s New Evidence Laws Section 10 of Indian Evidence Act vs Section 8 of Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam: Conspiracy and Acts of Conspirators Compared
Next Article Evidence Act vs BSA – India’s New Evidence Laws Section 5 of the Indian Evidence Act vs Section 4 of BSA: Facts in Issue and Relevant Facts Compared
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Follow US

Find US on Social Medias
FacebookLike
XFollow
InstagramFollow
YoutubeSubscribe
TelegramFollow
WhatsAppFollow

Weekly Newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter to get our newest articles instantly!
Popular News
IPC Section 307: A Perception On Attempted Murder
CriminalNewsSupreme Court

No Death Penalty If Reform Potential Exists, Even in Multiple Murder Cases: Supreme Court

Amna Kabeer
By Amna Kabeer
2 years ago
Denying Residence To Brother’s Wife In Shared Household Amounts To Domestic Violence: Bombay HC
Right to Voluntarily Close Business Under Article 19(1)(g): SC
Abuse Without Suicide Attempt Still Cruelty Under Section 498A IPC: J&K High Court
Authorities Cannot Withhold Pension Based On Single Instance Of Irregularity: Jharkhand HC
- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Your one-stop destination for legal news, articles, queries, and a directory of lawyers in India – all under one roof at ApniLaw.

Stay Updated

  • BNSS
  • News
  • Documentation
  • Acts
  • Supreme Court
  • High Court
  • Judgments

Information

  • ApniLaw Services
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service

Advertise

  • Advertise with us
  • Newsletters
  • Deal

Find Us on Socials

ApniLawApniLaw
Follow US
© ApniLaw 2026. All Rights Reserved.
login
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Or
Username or Email Address
Password

Lost your password?